Asset Returns and Positioning
The dominant portfolio assumption — that diversification across equities and bonds provides resilience — breaks down in the macro regimes that matter most: active devaluation, great power conflict, and late-cycle monetization. In those environments, financial assets move together toward the downside while real assets outperform in nominal terms. a-00098, a-00253
Core Historical Data
Asset returns during devaluation events (27 cases): a-00098, a-00253
- Gold: +81% average, +66% median
- Commodities: +55% average
- Equities: +34% average, +3% median (high variance)
- Nominal bonds: -5% average
Worst 20-year return periods across major countries (historical): a-00023
- Russia 1900-1918: -100% (complete market/property elimination)
- China 1930-1950: -100%
- Germany 1903-1923: -100% (hyperinflation)
- Japan 1928-1948: -96%
- France 1930-1950: -93%
Long-run real returns (1850–present): a-00015
- Cash (bills): +1.2% real average (but -0.1% since 1912)
- Gold: +1.3% real average (+1.6% since 1912)
Portfolio Construction Principle
“Portfolio framework: Rising Growth Assets (equities) vs Falling Growth Assets (bonds); Rising Inflation Assets (commodities/gold) vs Falling Inflation Assets (nominal bonds). Combined with country diversification.” — a-00021
The All Weather framework: hold assets that perform across all four macro environments (rising/falling growth × rising/falling inflation). In the current late-cycle environment (deteriorating growth + rising monetization risk), the balance shifts toward inflation-side assets.
Regime-Based Return Expectations
| Macro Regime | Winners | Losers |
|---|---|---|
| Sound money / early cycle | Equities, Bonds | Gold |
| Late cycle / high debt | Short-duration bonds, Gold | Long bonds |
| Active devaluation | Gold, Commodities, Real assets | Nominal bonds, Cash |
| War/great power conflict | Hard assets (country-specific) | Financial assets of belligerents |
| Post-war reconstruction | Equities (winners) | — |
Inference
The “bubble valuation signal” — the ratio of financial assets to total (real + financial) assets — captures when an economy has become over-financialized. At historical peaks, the ratio has reverted sharply. Current US readings are at or above prior bubble peaks by this measure. a-00047